Kohlmetz, Steen & Hanrahan, P.C. Portland Criminal Defense Attorneys
FREE Case Review email Location
Main Menu Office Location

Judge Finds FBI Actions Unreasonable

Conducting a search and seizure in the absence of a warrant requires a specific showing by law enforcement. The 4th Amendment to the Constitution prevents law enforcement from conducting "unreasonable" searches and seizures. Whether or not a search and seizure is considered unreasonable depends on a number of factors. In a recent case in Las Vegas, the Federal Bureau of Investigation conducted a warrantless search that was found to be unreasonable. The circumstances of the search would have broad implications if found reasonable.

The FBI wanted to get into a hotel room where they hoped to find evidence of illegal gambling. Without a warrant, this is no small task. The FBI decided to turn off Internet service to the hotel room in question and then pretended to be repairmen sent to fix the problem. The "repairmen" were FBI agents wearing hidden cameras. 

In finding the search to be unreasonable, the federal Judge suggested that the government could use the tactic to search the "vast majority of residences and hotel rooms in America." The FBI may have been banking on the search being found reasonable based on the consent of the accused in allowing the "repairmen" to enter the premises. While law enforcement is allowed to lie to a suspect, the act of obtaining consent to enter through false pretenses was apparently too much for the Judge to allow. Allowing the FBI to shut down someone's power, Internet, phone or cable is questionable. Allowing the FBI to do so in order to conduct a warrantless search is unreasonable.

Source: NBC News, "Judge: FBI's Ruse to Catch Poker Champ in Vegas Hotel Room Went Too Far," by Pete Williams, 17 April 2015 

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us To Schedule A Free And Confidential Initial Consultation

We are committed to delivering the dedicated, intelligent advocacy and personal service you deserve to help you through a difficult situation. Call us today at 888-311-2016 or send us an email below.

Send Email

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Kohlmetz, Steen & Hanrahan, P.C.

741 Southwest Lincoln Street
Portland, OR 97201
Portland Law Office Map
In portland: 503-224-1104
Toll Free: 888-311-2016
Fax: 503-224-9417